Reviews: Nothing Grows by Moonlight (6)
“Astonishing”
(Paperback)
Quite simply, one of the most haunting, honest and radical portraits of love and its resultant wreckage I have ever read. It’s astonishing, one to hold up in defence of the whole concept of the novel. An experience so visceral that it leaves you swallowing your fillings despite being, essentially, a story of two people having a quite long conversation.
It’s torturous, a glacial masterpiece of betrayal and lust. It’s humanity, ruining one another time and time again, beautifully. It might be perfect, certainly the best thing I have read this year.
“Haunting”
(Paperback)
"Nothing Grows by Moonlight," first published in Norway in 1947, is a rediscovered work revealing the unspoken struggles of women in a world that confines and ignores them. The story opens at a train station, where a man meets a mysterious woman. Over cigarettes and schnapps, she pours out her haunting past, recounting twenty years of pain and longing that have led her to this moment.
She recalls her youth as a small-town girl, dreaming of escape and beauty, only to become entangled in a doomed affair with her teacher. This relationship traps her in a cycle of heartbreak, hidden pregnancies, self-induced miscarriages, and societal shame. Her story becomes a indictment of the hypocrisy and cruelty women face under rigid moral codes that punish them for simply existing outside societal norms.
The novel offers a bleak sense of inevitability, capturing the psychological obsession and dependency that chains her to an abusive love. Her homelessness, both literal and emotional, reflects a soul searching for a place in a world that denies her autonomy and acceptance. Her longing for freedom and beauty stands tragically against the desolation of her circumstances.
For some, the novel’s sorrow may feel relentless and harrowing, yet the lyrical voice of the narrator lends a poetic light to the darkness, revealing a precious inner beauty even as her life crumbles. The prose, though sometimes heavy, gives a poignant and prescient voice to the female condition, reflecting the isolation and co-dependency many face in the pursuit of a life they are denied.
Nothing Grows by Moonlight is a haunting exploration of a woman’s yearning for life beyond the narrow limits of her birth.
“Sad, hopeless, yet hauntingly beautiful”
(Paperback)
First published in 1947, this novel tells the heart-breaking story of a young Norwegian girl from poor working family, whose life spirals out of control after she falls in love with a man who can never return her love in the same way. Her story offers a glimpse into the social injustices people of her class and sex had to endure. The hopelessness of her situation is very moving and society’s role in facilitating this sickening, especially as we still see parallels in today’s world. While the young woman’s story is compelling, the novel is structured in such a way that her telling of it is essentially one big monologue, which I found rather tiring. It is nonetheless a hauntingly beautiful piece of work.
“What sort of love grows in the moonlight?”
(Paperback)
"In the blue dusk of a spring evening, a man is drawn to a lonely, beautiful stranger across a station platform. She follows him home, and over one heady night of wine and cigarettes, recounts to him the devastating story of her life..."
First published in 1947, this Scandinavian novel is a feminist classic. You'll be drawn into the tale - eager to hear more of the rambling stream of consciousness told to a stranger. Nothing Grows by Moonlight tells the haunting tale of one woman's doomed obsession with her teacher when she was seventeen. He seems like a light in the dark, dull monotony of her life and family in a small town. Her mother has a dreary life and is happy with what she has. This woman wants more and takes more.
“Harrowing and inevitable”
(Paperback)
I'm not the fastest reader but it took me a while to get through this one. I could put it down. It meandered at times, repeated itself (arguably it didn't, it was the unrealiable and emotional narrator who did that), and lacked some pace. Emotion and intrigue ran high as an enigmatic woman recounts her haunting background to a stranger. If felt like it was building to a crescendo and dramatic reveal, but for me it didn't quite hit a high. That's not to say it wasn't a devasting story full of passion, heartbreak, and the impossible position of women in society. No doubt in 1947, when this book was first published, it would have been more impactful than it feels now.
Page of 2

Nothing Grows by Moonlight
Fiction, General Fiction
Torborg Nedreaas (author) , Bibbi Lee (translator)
Paperback Published on: 06/03/2025
Price: £12.99
