Reviews: Fire (66)
“A superbly well written, morally complex and nuanced, compelling read”
(Hardback)
On the face of it, Freya lives a gilded existence, dancing solely to her own tune. She has all the trappings of wealth and privilege, a responsible job as a surgeon specialising in skin grafts, a beautiful flat in a sought-after development, and a flash car. But it wasn’t always like this. Hers is a life founded on darkness.
Did what happened to Freya as a child one fateful summer influence the adult she would become – or was she always destined to be that person? Was she born with cruelty in her heart or did something force it into being?
It is very hard to review this novella fully without giving away spoilers, but suffice to say, in Fire, John Boyne is asking the age-old question: is it nurture or nature that makes a person who and what they are? Are we the product of our genetics and parentage, or is it our experiences and the way we're brought up that are key? Or, perhaps it is a bit of both?
The novel also asks questions about and explores a number of other serious, and moral issues such as the nature of abuse, and if one Gender inherently predisposed to be more violent and abusive than the other?
Definitions of victimhood and victim blaming are challenged along with the assumptions that exist about who perpetrators and victims might be, and, in an acute, almost philosophical way, Boyne paints a picture of how it might be entirely feasible to be both victim and perpetrator at the same time.
Fire is part of Boyne's Elements quartet, with characters, situations and themes from the previous titles threading through and rippling in and out. With one remaining title, Air, still to come, it is fascinating to see how the threads which link all of the titles are being skilfully drawn together.
As with Water and Earth, Fire has a distinctly chilling, uncomfortable, and even disturbing feel. This is a series unafraid of dealing with difficult subjects, and with challenging, controversial and sensitive issues, in the way only John Boyne can.
Whilst it is a quick read, which can be completed in one sitting, it has immense complexity and depth, and it bears all the hallmark characteristics of Boyne's masterly and often contentious writing. Inevitably, all of this means that there are multiple trigger warnings, which some readers may be wise to research first, prior to reading.
However if you are looking for a superbly well written, morally complex and nuanced, compelling read which raises much food for thought, this is definitely one for you. Guaranteed to live on in your head long after you've turned the final page.
Thank you to Doubleday UK for early access to this title.
“Incredibly gripping”
(Hardback)
Aged 12 Freya finds herself in a horrifying situation, to say the least. On the surface, Freya, now in her 30s, seems like a caring, dedicated surgeon specialising in skin graft; underneath, however,... Did the incident in her childhood turn her into the woman she is today, or was she going to be this person, regardless?
John Boyne has done it again, putting the reader through a multitude of emotions with this book. I'm hesitant to call it a brilliant read, mainly because the subject matter is rather unsettling. But, I wil to admit, it's incredibly gripping.
“Another masterpiece from John Boyne”
(Hardback)
Fire follows consultant burns doctor Freya’s story. A highly successful doctor with a hidden deeply dark and disturbing past, which plays a pivotal role in the woman she has become.
John Boyne is truly remarkable; he shies away from nothing, tackling highly emotive topics head on; and this novella certainly shakes up the stereotypical narrative and tackles a truly uncomfortable theme. This is a truly challenging read in that you feel totally unsettled and disturbed reading it, yet it is absolutely compelling and unputdownable. One to read and discuss with a friend.
I can’t wait for the final book in the quartet, Air
Huge thanks to the publisher, Random House UK, Transworld and NetGalley for an arc in exchange for a review.
“The Secret Bookreview.”
(Hardback)
On the surface, Freya appears to live a life of luxury and privilege: a respected surgeon specializing in skin grafts, residing in a beautiful flat, and driving a flashy car. Yet beneath this gilded exterior lies a dark past, one that shapes the woman she has become. In Fire, John Boyne delves into the chilling and complex psychological landscape of Freya, prompting readers to ponder whether her cruelty was inherent or forged by the traumatic events of her childhood.
As the third instalment in Boyne's Elements Quartet, Fire takes readers on an uncomfortable but utterly captivating journey into the heart of the human condition. Boyne skillfully raises the age-old question of nature versus nurture, forcing us to grapple with our perceptions of victimhood and perpetration.
The narrative unfolds in such a way that it demands to be read in one sitting. Freya's story, laden with horrific childhood experiences, reveals her dark path of retribution as an adult. While she dedicates her professional life to healing burn victims, her personal life spirals into a sinister realm that contrasts sharply with her surgical prowess.
Freya’s work is supported by her secretary, Louise, and a new intern, Aaron, whom she tolerates with reluctance. Yet, as she navigates the complex dynamics of the hospital, we begin to see the depths of her internal struggles and the darkness that shadows her existence.
Boyne pushes societal boundaries, challenging readers to confront their discomfort with personal tragedies and the punishments that ensue. His manipulation of our thoughts and emotions blurs the lines between victim and perpetrator, making it difficult to discuss the plot without revealing crucial spoilers. However, threads linking this book to its predecessors, Earth and Water, enrich the overall narrative and invite further reflection.
Fire is sure to spark debate and introspection, lingering in readers’ minds long after the last page is turned. Boyne’s masterful storytelling illuminates the often-ignored realities faced by victims of violence while also exploring the psychological toll on those who inflict harm.
Read more at The Secret Bookreview.
“Compelling and shocking”
(Hardback)
This is the third in the amazing Elements quartet by John Boyne. The first two were fantastic reads. This one is superb. It is shocking. It deals with the worst that humans can do to each other and also with human fragility. Child abuse, rape of children, torture and murder are all there. I'm sure there are many readers who will be shocked and stop reading but I felt it was written in such a way that compelled me to continue reading if only to find out how it ended. And I was so glad I did! The character of Freya is written so well that even at her adult worst you can still feel what she went through as that poor confused 12 year old girl looking for someone to love her. Definitely a set of novellas not to be missed.
Page of 14

Fire
Fiction, General Fiction
John Boyne (author)
Hardback Published on: 07/11/2024
Price: £12.99
