Reviews: Fellow Creatures (5)
“Drama and drama”
(Hardback)
I devoured this in the span of 24 hours because it’s just that gripping and readable.
At its core, Fellow Creatures is a cautionary tale against the lengths obsession will take you, even if, at face value, that obsession seems to pay off.
Shannon, our protagonist, is 18 years old and just about to start 3 years at a prestigious London drama school. From the very beginning, the first-person narration drips with subtle self-deprecation and the unfortunate need to impress as she irreversible enters the orbit of Victoria, a fellow student and the object of Shannon’s evolving infatuation.
What follows is an exploration of a complex and toxic friendship, with Shannon always feeling several steps behind Victoria. It was so incredibly interesting to follow along with Shannon’s narrative voice, because it’s obvious she loathes and loves Victoria in equal measure and can never quite allow herself to champion one feeling over the other. She constantly compares herself to Victoria, bristles at throwaway comments Victoria makes that are intended to hurt, and even preens when she is sometimes compared to Victoria (not a positive comparison, fyi). Shannon presents herself as a tangled tapestry of despising the way Victoria treats her and craving nothing but her attention.
The friendship group revolving around this pair were also thoroughly engaging, and each battled their own various issues as they ploughed their way through the same 3-year stint of drama school. Jolly, for example, as a young gay man fears being typecast and fears for his future as an actor. Stefano, misogynist at heart and not very likable, constantly feels judged and looked down upon by his friends. Obi, kind and thoughtful, engages in a seemingly fraught relationship with Victoria at the same time as trying to keep the peace within the group.
And at the centre of it all, causing conflict where none need exist, is the Mean Girl herself. Victoria’s cruelty was always subtle, always skirting that nebulous edge where Shannon wonders if she’s misreading the situation. Maybe she’s overthinking things. Maybe Victoria didn’t mean it that way. Maybe hounding Stefano into a blazing row was because Victoria was drunk, and not because she just loves causing chaos and upset.
And this is where Victoria is such a masterful character. Her actions can be reasoned away, even if we as the reader understand that her every action and word is deliberate. She knows exactly what she’s doing, and she does it so well. The whole time, you’re rooting for Shannon to come to her senses and sever the toxic friendship, even if at the same time you want the torment to continue to see just what Victoria will say or do next.
Overall, I loved this book. It touches upon the unfair expectations education places on young people at the same time as gorily dissecting the catastrophic bonds that form between these stressed, harried individuals.
Thank you to the publisher for my early reader copy.
“Saltburn meets Mr Ripley”
(Hardback)
This is a propulsive read that really builds tension. I finished it in a day, and then couldn't stop thinking about it. The audio book is read by the author which is so good and well paced, that after listened to the trailer I'm now hooked in again!
“A story of friendship, desire, and jealousy”
(Hardback)
’Love makes us do mad and terrible things’
Emerald Fennell’s Saltburn meets Mona Awad’s All’s Well in Fellow Creatures - a story of desire, envy-fuelled infatuation, and the gruelling world of theatre. We follow Shannon Bell, a working-class northerner who begins an acting degree in London, all with the hope of finally becoming seen. There she meets Victoria - beautiful, charismatic, talented and wealthy - and quickly becomes caught up in the whirlwind of her life. But as friendship turns to obsession, and obsession turns to jealousy, it becomes clear that the stage might not have enough space for the two of them.
Fellow Creatures fits a very distinct niche of academic rivalry that I just adore - two talented women fighting to make their mark on the world, all while working through their own fractured relationship with one another. It’s a premise that I am drawn to instantly, perhaps due to my own fascination with careers I will never compete for a place in, like acting, law, medicine, or music. The competitiveness of these professions seems to draw out the best or the utter worst in people, and there is nothing more entertaining, in my opinion.
Lowther did an utterly fantastic job at crafting such a layered, distinct, and tense relationship between Victoria and Shannon, one that was so well-written that it dominated every aspect of the story. I couldn’t tear my eyes to the page, I was just so caught up in the charged atmosphere that seemed to fill the pages of this book. Both characters had unique and fascinating personalities and backgrounds, made even more impactful due to their innate differences, and similarities, with one another. Class and privilege play a central role to the narrative, and they are tackled with respect and nuance - the conversation around Victoria’s ‘prestigious’ upbringing, compared to her peers lower-class childhoods, was brilliant.
Overall, Fellow Creatures gets 4.5/5 stars rounded up to 5/5 stars for Goodreads, Waterstones, and Netgalley. A truly captivating debut, that I won’t be forgetting about any time soon.
thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
“The secret history meets Saltburn in the best possible way”
(Hardback)
Set in the claustrophobic, competitive world of a London drama school, Fellow Creatures is the kind of debut that grabs you and simply does not let go. Victoria is a fascinating, deeply frustrating character, and Shannon’s conflicted feelings towards her, somewhere between devotion and resentment, are written with real emotional intelligence. The twist genuinely changes everything. Jolly and Obi provide some much-needed warmth among the chaos, and the pacing is perfect for a long sit-down read. A dark, glittering, completely addictive thriller.
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
“One hell of a strong debut!”
(Hardback)
Literary fiction is not my usual genre, but I was instantly intrigued by this one when I learned that it's a sub pick in one of my boxes. And I'm so glad I gave it a chance, because what a fantastic debut!
Admittedly, I don't know too much about the reality of drama schools, but I immensely enjoyed that setting for this book with the ruthless competition and academic rivalry, especially combined with the complex cast of characters.
So much toxicity and obsession, I found it both disturbing and weirdly addicting! I knew things were going to go terribly wrong, but I had no idea how or when, so I simply couldn't look away.
There weren't really any points in the story where I knew for sure who to trust or who had Shannon's best interest at heart and who was faking it. Victoria was the hardest to read, what a masterfully crafted character.
Fair warning, it is a very dark story where multiple characters are subject to verbal bullying and have mental health issues.
Overall, I thought the ending was a very fitting conclusion, and if the trigger warnings don't deter you, I do think Fellow Creatures will blow you away too.
Thank you to Quercus, NetGalley and the author for the digital ARC. All opinions are my own.
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
Page of 1

Fellow Creatures
Fiction, General Fiction
Emma Lowther (author)
Hardback Published on: 25/06/2026
Price: £20.00
