Reviews: Eradication (5)
“Great read!”
(Hardback)
Great read!
I'm not sure I was meant to find this as funny as I did, given the heavy subject matter. However, between the descriptions of goats and Adi's inner monologue, I was chuckling throughout.
If you enjoy obscure tales that explore solitude, nature, and morality, please read this. You won't be disappointed.
Thank you NetGalley and Quercus Books for allowing me to read the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
“Short and snappy”
(Hardback)
This was an odd little story, clocking in at less than 200 pages. It follows a man, Adi, who's recently suffered great emotional upheaval, and as a result has decided to take on a strange job that involves him spending 5 weeks on an isolated island as he deals with the population of invasive goats there.
The message that runs prevalent throughout is one I think we can all get behind. Adi's development as he grapples with the task he's been assigned and the skewed morality behind it was engaging to read. Alongside Adi, we're forced to confront the consequences our actions as a species have on the landscape and on the animals we drag into our destructive orbit. What starts out as a tale about the invasive goats (who are framed initially as malevolent in their 'destruction' of the island) needing to be removed becomes a narrative about shifting the blame and demonising creatures that, through no fault of their own, were introduced to the island by their human owners.
I just wish this one had been a little longer. The ending was such a satisfying gut-punch that I wanted just a little bit more of it, to provide a more decisive conclusion.
Thanks to the publisher for access to an advance copy.
“A Desert Island Study of Grief and Morality”
(Hardback)
Such a weird little story in the best way! At times darkly funny, this extremely poignant reflection of grief questions an individual’s morality, drawing your attention to the euphemisms and lies we tell ourselves to justify our actions. It’s a wonderfully short tale that, despite its short length, packs a gut punch of emotions. I flew through this in one sitting!
“A fascinating and absorbing read.”
(Hardback)
An extraordinary story about the effect of humans upsetting the natural flora and fauna by introducing a non-indigenous species into an area, namely goats.
The way the authorities have decided to address this is to eradicate the goats and they recruit Adi to go to the island to sort out the problem. I love the humour at the beginning of the book and the description of the island and the goats. Things become darker as we learn that Adi has suffered tragedy in his life that he is coming to terms with and his thoughts as he realises the consequences of this task he has undertaken. I wasn’t expecting the ending that came, but in a way it was inevitable. It leaves you with much food for thought!
Beautifully written with an excellent storyline. A fascinating and absorbing read.
Many thanks to Jonathan Miles, Quercus and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an early copy.
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
“Short and profound - 3.5 stars”
(Hardback)
Eradication is a short story about Adi, who accepts a job on the remote island of Santa, tasked with exterminating invasive goats, introduced by whalers that have decimated the islands unique flora and fauna.
We follow Adi as he deals with personal grief and his own beliefs, as he contemplates whether or not he can actually complete the task at hand and if it’s even right to do it at all. The agonising over his decision is exacerbated by fishermen he encounters who are illegally killing sharks which Adi is vehemently against.
I was pleasantly surprised by Eradication. When I saw it on NetGalley, it sounded so different that I requested it right away! I wasn’t sure how much heft such a short story could have but Miles manages to pack a lot into the 160 pages. The discussion that runs throughout the book about our impact on the natural world is thought-provoking, and Adi’s character development is dealt with well despite the short length.
I’d recommend this if you’re looking for something short but impactful, or if you want to read something a little different. Thanks to NetGalley, Quercus Books and of course Jonathan Miles for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
Page of 1

Eradication
Fiction, General Fiction
Jonathan Miles (author)
Hardback Published on: 05/02/2026
Price: £14.99
