Reviews: Common Decency (44)
“A Subtle, Humorous Novel About Community Ties and the Secrets They Hold”
(Hardback)
I did enjoy this offering from Tom Allen, though not quite as much as I’d hoped. I couldn’t shake the feeling that it would have landed even better as an audiobook, read by Tom himself, because his voice and rhythm are so clearly woven through the story. On the surface it’s about a group of residents banding together to save an old oak tree, but there’s so much more happening beneath that premise — layers of personal struggle, community tension and the quiet ways people try to do the right thing.
Oak Drive is a small road opposite a little park with a very old oak tree at its heart. The residents keep an eye on one another, so when the council announces plans to turn the park into an electric charging station — removing the ancient oak in the process — they rally together. But nothing on Oak Drive is quite what it seems. Donald, the self appointed ruler of the road and dictator of his long suffering wife Fanny, is hiding more than anyone realises. Alice, the local doctor, has fallen out of love with her husband Barry, and he’s floundering as he tries to fix what he doesn’t understand. Vince and Nathan Luke, the new couple on the street, have poured themselves into creating their dream home, but they too are carrying secrets. And Miranda, the sweet elderly lady of the close, may not be quite the harmless figure everyone assumes.
In the end, what stood out most for me was the blend of gentle humour and the very human messiness behind each closed door on Oak Drive. Tom Allen captures the quirks, flaws and quiet heartbreaks of his characters with real warmth, even if the story didn’t fully land for me in the way I’d hoped. It’s a thoughtful, often tender look at the small acts of kindness and courage that hold a community together, especially when hidden truths surface and ordinary people find themselves making a difference.
“Entertaining cozy novel”
(Hardback)
I absolutely love Tom Allen and his dry acerbic wit so I had high hopes for this book. It’s a cozy character driven story about a small road, Oak Drive, which has just four houses in it. A fairly large cast of characters all with equal billing - Vince and Nathan who have just moved in, overbearing Donald and his mousy wife Fanny, GP Alice and her laid back (so far back almost falling over) husband Barry (and their two children) and retired Miranda who was my favourite character, totally bonkers but fun.
Briefly, there isn’t much of a plot, it is more of an expose of the secrets the various characters are hiding. The only real plot running through the story is the neighbours trying to save the small park and its ancient oak tree, opposite their homes, which the council want to turn into a vehicle charging point centre. Other notable events include illegal drug dealing and a queer performance of Joseph and his Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, you get the idea!
There is a bee at the beginning of the novel that returns at the end and I think more could have been (no pun intended) made of this. I liked the bee! It’s all very far fetched and there is a lot going on, I did get lost a couple of times about who was narrating but was reading an e-arc so the layout may have been tidied up. It was a pleasant story but I think I set my expectations too high. I did wonder if the author was voicing an audio book as I thought that would work well. It was worth the read and I would read more from the author. A cozy entertaining book.
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
“Common Decency”
(Hardback)
Once I got over the fact that maybe this guy's sense of humour doesn't quite match mine - especially wrt the crass joke he pulls very early on I had a better time once the story really got going.
We meet the inhabitants of Oak Drive - just 4 houses situated by a small park complete with the eponymous tree, a community centre, local shop and hairdressers.
Three of the houses' occupants have lived there for a while, but there is a new couple on the block, Vince and Nathan Luke, and everyone wants to know their background, and involve them into the community. Meanwhile we also get to know Miranda who although getting on in years, is still young at heart and has a bit of a wild past. Then there's Fanny and Donald - chalk and cheese. He's a bit of a bully all told. Finally, we have Barry and Alice and their two kids. They are going through a bit of a sticky patch in their marriage. The usually ticking along, not really trying stuff...
But then there's a note from the council planning department informing them of a new development which threatens both the park and their peace, as well as the tree! Will this be enough to unite and ignite our characters into action...?
The focus of the book switches between the four households so you meet them and get to know them gradually. Maybe too gradually. I think for me the focus switched too often and too soon and, as a consequence, I didn't feel I bonded with any of them properly. And they all went through quite a lot of change as the book developed, most of which felt forced rather than natural. Despite the main trigger being the threat to the park and tree, I though it all happened too coincidentally to be really believable. And cos it is a very character driven book, the characters have to be able to hold up the story and I don't feel they did here.
The story itself flowed reasonably well and there were a few shocks and surprises along the way. But I felt that the ending felt a little flat and I didn't finish the book with much of a satisfied feeling.
All in all, I think that this is probably a case of me as a reader not really getting on with him as an author. Some of the jokes hit home, other's fell quite flat, some even irked me a tad.
“Okayish.”
(Hardback)
‘Common Decency’ offers a caricature of English suburbia, replete with shallow stereotypes and reveals so predictable I could have sworn the information had been overtly stated earlier in the novel. It has a fairly amusing tone overall—if you can get past the initial infantile joke, that is—though the situations it presents and the characters’ actions are far from realistic, and it lacks anything even resembling plot.
The cast is large, but due to the cartoonish nature in which they are written, they feel reasonably distinct after the first eighty pages or so. However, their lack of depth and the author’s heavy use of filtering and telling, creating a substantial narrative distance, makes it hard to connect with any of them. Plus, none of them have any goals, which makes them impossible to root for.
The writing is okay, but in need of tighter editing. Ungrammatical constructions and head-hopping are a frequent occurrence, and they make for a jarring and disorienting read. The writing also trends towards a melodramatic, soap-opera-esque quality as it nears the end. This is particularly true of the big reveal, which somehow manages to be both predictable and completely unfounded in the story up to that point, and of the climactic scene—though, to call it ‘climactic’ is a stretch, as that would suggest a culmination and resolution, whereas this is just a random, big event shoved on the end.
‘Common Decency’ could be a good choice for you if you’re looking for an undemanding and vaguely amusing read; however, if you’re in the mood for a well-written story with characters you can care about, you’d be better off picking something else.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Tom Allen and Hodder & Stoughton for the ARC.
⚠️ Drug use, alcohol
This reviewer received a free of charge product for review.
Page of 9

Common Decency
Fiction, General Fiction
Tom Allen (author)
Hardback Published on: 21/05/2026
Price: £20.00
